Yesterday an article in The New York times highlighted the results of a media industry report from the private equity firm Veronis Suhler Stevenson (VSS):

An interesting shift occurred in 2008, the report said. For the first time, consumers spent more time with media they paid for, like books or cable television, than with primarily ad-supported media, like newspapers and magazines.

The VSS report also forecast internet media and subscription television to be sectors of strong growth during the next four years. These trends echoes the results mentioned in another report released a few weeks ago by Strategic Analytics (SA), which forecast that the global paid online video segment will surpass the ad-based online video segment in 2009. The SA report also forecast stronger growth for the paid segment during the next four years.

Both studies partly attribute the shift in balance towards paid content to the recession, which has stifled advertising budgets in both traditional and online media. In any case it is still surprising is to hear that paid video content will be a bigger moneymaker than ad-based content. While some companies like Apple and Netflix have made headway in the paid video segment a lot of studies have indicated that consumers prefer ad-supported models; an IBM study in November 2008 indicated that 70% of consumers prefer ad-supported models over consumer-paid models. Another study by Deloitte yielded similar results, indicating that 67% of US consumers aged between 25 and 34 would “be willing to be exposed to online ads in exchange for free content.

Although the majority of consumers would opt for ad-based video models, perhaps the smaller pay-to-watch segment is willing to outspend advertisers as a whole, in return for the following benefits:

• Zero or less advertising
• Access to a wider range of content (recent movies, old TV episodes, etc.)
• Ownership of the material or a longer viewing window
• Option to watch across more types of hardware (computers, DVR, mobile, etc.)
• Higher viewing quality

Given these trends in these reports during next two years the online community will see an expansion in paid video content. The ‘TV Everywhere’ partnership was recently launched by Time Warner and Comcast, allowing Comcast subscribers to view video online from TBS, TNT, CBS and HBO. I am also wondering if ad-based sites like Hulu will add paid content options; perhaps a subscription service similar to Netflix for accessing all the episodes for a series. Will hybrid sites emerge, offering both ad-based and pay-to-watch options? It is probably to early to guess which models will win (Hulu was launched only 17 months ago; see graphic above) but it is probable that a greater variety of options will emerge, resulting in a more choices and a very dynamic market.